evandar: (Loki)
So. I saw the new Fantastic Beasts on Friday and again on Saturday, and I’ve been left with thoughts. Many, many thoughts. And I’ll freely admit that I’d watch it again to see if there’s anything that I’ve overlooked, but that’s going to have to wait since cinema tickets are fucking expensive.

Anyway, many of the reviews that I’ve read on this film have been mixed and, of course, there was a lot of controversy heading up to the release. The casting of Johnny Depp as Grindelwald disappointed a lot of people – myself included. He’s…not a great decision, and there’ll be more on my thoughts under the cut. There was also the Nagini reveal, which has some horrendous racist connotations and some very ugly implications for the Harry Potter series – again, more under the cut. So with all of that up in the air before the release, I wasn’t entirely sure what to expect going into it. In all honesty, I felt slightly dubious, and official write-ups of the movie have been…eh. The Mary Sue keeps crossing my Facebook feed, and they’ve been particularly scathing, but the general overview seems to be that it’s a decent enough watch but over-stuffed with plots and some quite unpleasant twists. I can’t say that this review is going to be any different.

It's also long. So very long.

So spoilers under the cut!

”SPOILERS” )
evandar: (Default)
One of the strangest things about embarking on this degree has been the fan studies aspect of it. Don't get me wrong, it was entirely my choice to include a chapter on fandom in my thesis. It's just...the hoop jumping? I had to fill out an ethics form and have it signed off by a committee in order to do something that I've already been doing on a daily(ish) basis for the last fourteen years - that is, talk to people on the internet.

It's all for a very good reason - one that I'm 100% behind - but that doesn't mean it's not surreal.

Also surreal is the ability to turn around and go 'oh hell no' to some of the books I have to read and then proceed to nitpick the fuck out of them.

I mean, a book of essays on Harry Potter crossed my To Read pile earlier this week. (I say that like I hadn't checked it out of the library weeks ago and then only just got round to reading it yesterday, which is what actually happened.) And yeah. My thesis isn't even on Harry Potter, but thanks to the sheer span of fandoms covered in transmedia and fandom studies, I kind of had to read it anyway. (At least it wasn't Star Trek. Again.) And I couldn't take it seriously. At all. I ripped it to shreds and then handed it back feeling vaguely guilty like I should be ashamed of myself for landing so hard on the fan side of aca/fandom.

I mean, there was this one essay that could have been fantastic - it was all about the medical side of the Potter series - had the author...read the books first? Just tiny details that didn't really detract from his point but that turned me into that person regardless.

Meta, in which I actually defend Dumbledore, under the cut... )
TL;DR: I'm still more of a fangirl than I am an academic and I waffle a lot.

(Crossposted to my LJ.)

Profile

evandar: (Default)
evandar

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
45678 910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated May. 24th, 2025 04:27 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios